No Confidence Motion: Shiv Sena abstains from voting, BJD walks out

Shiv sena on Friday said that it will abstain from voting in the no confidence motion against the Modi govt. After a party meeting, Senior leader of Shiv sena, Sanjay Raut said that 18 Shiv sena MPs will not attend the proceedings of Lok Sabha and will not vote in the no confidence motion.

Biju Janata Dal (BJD) also walks out ahead of the proceeding of the Lok Sabha and will not participate in the no confidence motion.

Meanwhile Jayadev Galla of TDP in a speech presented his party side and accused Modi government for biased behaviour with the people of Andhra Pradesh (AP) and not fulfilling the promises he made with the people of AP. Lok Sabha speaker Sumitra Mahajan said that the voting on the no confidence motion will take place today at 6:00 PM.

UP Police launches digital volunteers’ campaign to curb spread of rumors on social media

Amid growing concerns over the rise in incidents of mob lynching in the last few days the Uttar Pradesh police decided to hire 250 digital volunteers at each of the 1,469 police stations to curb mob lynching incidents and circulation of rumors or fake news on social media.

According to OP Singh, Uttar Pradesh Director General of Police (DGP), UP Police, with 4,41,000 Twitter followers, is the most active on social media platform.

“Now we are launching our digital volunteers’ campaign. Every police station will have 250 digital volunteers, they will play a key role in busting rumors and will report any illegal activities in the locality,” added OP Singh.

UP Police took to Twitter and shared the campaign, “Your opportunity to be a digital volunteer of #UPPolice is here. If you are a peace-loving, law-abiding, socially and digitally active citizen of UP then join hands with us in our first of its kind community policing initiative in the country.”

These digital volunteers will comprise school teachers, retired servicemen, principals, doctors, journalists, priests, maulvis and other public representatives residing within the jurisdiction of each of the police stations.

The process will select two individuals from every village or locality who will be interacting through WhatsApp group and the group will be monitored by a policeman at every police station for updates 24×7.

The volunteers will be short-listed by a committee headed by the district police chief. 

Missing Pro-Peace Pakistan activist returns

Raza Mehmood Khan, a 40-year old Pakistani peace activist and the convener of Aaghaz-e-Dosti (an organisation promoting friendly ties between Pakistan and India), who was mysteriously abducted by unknown persons from his house on on December 2, 2017, has been recovered.

Rashid Wani, personal secretary to the president of the Commission of Enquiry on Enforced Disappearances, reportedly said that Khan was recovered by Model Town police and had returned home safely.

While speaking to a Pak journalist Wani said, “Raza Khan was recovered by Model Town police 10 days ago.”

Wani further said the abducted peace activist had returned home safely. The commission claimed SP Investigation Model Town Lahore reported the matter to them after Khan’s recovery. The Pak journalist contacted SP Model Town Imran Sethi to know who had abducted Raza, what was the motive behind it. However, the police official turned him away.

Khan went missing in 2017 after participating in an open discussion event on extremism.

Khan’s close friends also confirmed that he had reached home. They said Raza was in good health.

Drugs & Deaths: Tokenism can only win brownie points, not war against drugs

IT HAS TAKEN 18 long months for the Punjab Chief Minister Captain Amarinder Singh to finally launch his much-hyped battle against drugs when alarming number of deaths due to overdose of drugs jolted the nation. He has ordered mandatory drug tests for government employees numbering about 3.25 lakh including the police. The Cabinet has also decided to recommend death penalty to drug-peddlers by amending NDPS Act. It is a common knowledge that drugs enter Punjab from the Golden Crescent (Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan) through the 553-km porous border and make their way to the rest of the country. This makes it a national problem and a serious security threat. This requires a concerted battle against drugs and community involvement to find the root cause of this menace.

Steps like compulsory dope test and death penalty for drug dealers may sound deterrent but do not guarantee a win over drugs. World over death penalty has almost been abolished and is reserved for the rarest of the rare crimes. Little doubt such steps appear to be a piece of tokenism because of the enormity of the problem with estimates pointing out that there is a drug addict in every two-thirds of households in Punjab. It is not that drug addicts and dealers are not being arrested.

Last year alone 18,977 peddlers were arrested and sent to jails. Data from the National Crime Records Bureau pertaining to cases registered under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances suggests that of all cases registered across the country over 30 per cent are from Punjab alone.

A problem of this magnitude requires a national war against the menace. Drug mafia exists because they enjoy political patronage and a large number of police personnel have been found to be actively involved in this illegal trade. However, an overwhelming majority of those arrested under the NDPS Act are addicts caught with small quantities of drugs. They are mere pawns for drug mafias. There is a need to identify the real causes of drug addiction and why youths are falling preys and taking to drugs in such large numbers. Should not the law enforcement agencies tackle the drug mafias with all their might.

The stakeholders need to find out if our education system that is bereft of hopes of an assured future and employment needs to be overhauled? The authorities need to study if the youth is drifting to escapism by taking to drugs? Some villages have taken upon themselves the task of fighting out drug peddlers by nabbing them and handing them over to the police. Here the government needs to see if this would not turn out to be another form of dreaded vigilantism?

Poor Infrastructure Hinders Functioning At De-Addiction Units

In the grip of an alarming drugs menace, Punjab is struggling hard to get over the problem lately with little hope of success. In the last two months 30 people have died of drugs overdose. These are of course recorded cases. There are so many others whose deaths are not even recorded for fear of shame. Desperate to curb the problem, Punjab Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh even suggested death penalty for first-time drug offenders, but the idea may not be feasible, said experts.

Poor infrastructure of treatment and rehabilitation centres for drug patients haunts Punjab. Low number of convictions is another major flaw in dealing with the problem at hand. The Patients count in the state is huge and de-addiction centres with bed facilities is inadequate. According to official figures, total number of patients who came for treatment in Punjab in both government and private centres in the year 2016 was 1.49 lakh and 1.08 lakh in 2017. Figures for 2018 are yet to be compiled. Punjab government runs 37 de-addiction centre and 22 rehabilitation centres in the state. Unofficial figures of the drug patients in Punjab is more than three lakh.

To cater to the patients, there are just 96 de-addiction and 77 private rehabilitation centres in the state, but these are not enough for the large number of patients.

Talking to Tehelka, Dr Debashish Basu — MD, DNB, MAMS —Professor of Psychiatry, Drug De-addiction and Treatment Centre, Department of Psychiatry. Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh — said beds available at PGI Drug-deactivation centre is just 20 and only 18 patients are admitted at present. “Around 2,000 new patients come for treatment at the PGI every year and 8000 drug patients come annually for follow-up measures,” said Dr Basu.

Dr Basu said success rate of treatment of Drug patients depends on how one defines ‘success’. If it’s a narrow abstinence oriented definition (totally abstinent from all drugs for at least three years) then the percentage is very low at 20-30 per cent. If it’s a broad, functionally-oriented definition (eg. Occasional lapses, but no major relapse, functioning reasonably well in family, occupational and society with no major setbacks, then the percentage will be 40 to 60 per cent. It also depends on the type of drugs and many other factors. said Dr Basu.

Incidentally Punjab Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh had taken a vow that he will wipe out the drug problem within a month of coming to power. But he has failed miserably. Now, almost one and a half years later there seems no way the problem can even be contained, leave aside be resolved.

The government has tried several measures to check the growing drug problem, but the results have not been very encouraging. In the recent months there has been a massive crackdown on the drug peddlers and smugglers. As a result Punjab is reportedly set for a record seizure of heroin this year.

But what is worrying is the low number of convictions of smugglers in the last two years. In the first six months of this year in Punjab, a record 215 kgs of heroin was seized by the police, BSF, NCB and other agencies. In 2017, only 193 kgs of heroin was recovered. Similarly last year 1,915.7 kg of ganja was recovered by the police in Punjab, but this year in the first six month itself 1,817.06 kg of it has been recovered.

However, the Punjab police have been under fire for the poor conviction rate as they failed to gather enough evidence against drug smugglers and ultimately they were set free by the High Court. According to the Punjab CAG report, more than 700 cases of drug smuggling had failed because the prosecutions were not proper or because of poor evidence gathered by the police.

The number of drug patients in Punjab is huge and in lakhs. Drug patients count has risen alarmingly in the last few years. Naturally, patients seeking help to get rid of the addiction too is very large. This puts pressure on the drug de-addiction centres as they are finding it difficult to deal with such large number of addicted persons. Around 1,400 patients had been admitted in various de-addiction centres of the state.

Most of the private de-addiction centres in the state cater to local patients. A visit to the Aakash Hospital in Gulmohar complex, Kharar, in the outskirts of Mohali revealed several patients waiting for their turn for treatment. “We are a 10-bedded hospital and provide the best of treatment to the patients at a reasonable cost. There are many such centres in Kharar tehsil itself,” said Dr Jivan Babu, medical in-charge of the hospital.

According to Dr Jivan Babu, only in serious cases only patients are admitted. Otherwise they can get treatment from home. But cases of relapse happen more where the patients are at home during treatment and there is no proper monitoring of their activities. “Will power of the patient counts a lot. He must ensure to stay away from drugs after treatment. Unfortunately, after treatment the patients go back to their friends and relatives who are addicted. Once the patients start taking drugs again, the same medicines have to be repeated,” said Dr Jivan Babu.

Talking to Tehelka, relatives of a patient Bhupinder Singh, (name changed) resident of Kurali, said Bhupinder’s elder brother too had become a victim of the drugs a couple of years ago. The family is engaged in farming. It was Bhupinder who was looking after the family. But a few months ago he started behaving strangely. Later it was discovered that he had become a victim of drugs through the friends of his elder brother. Bhupinder was brought for treatment. Initially he responded well, but later he went back to drugs and that created a problem. The relatives do not have enough money to admit him to the hospital so he stays at home and gets treatment. But the family fears he may start taking drugs again after treatment due to its easy availability in the surrounding areas.

“Unless the patient is willing to quit the habit himself, it is very difficult to force him to do so as he will go back to his old ways at the first opportunity,” said Dr Jiban Babu.

Doctors at private de-addiction centres are unwilling to share number of patients treated. They have a reason to do so also as the Punjab Substance Use Disorder Treatment and Counselling and Rehabilitation Centre Rules, 2011, prohibits the medical professionals from sharing patient records.

A doctor in the Psychiatry Department at the PGIMER, Chandigarh who would not like to be named, said the problem at hand is getting out of control and it is very difficult to even contain it now. The question is if all the stakeholders including the doctors and private and government hospitals are willing to go the distance for checking the growing menace that threatens to engulf the society now.

According to official figures, more than 3,000 drug patients were treated at Jalandhar Civil Hospital and Community health Centre in Nurmahal this year. Sources said there has been a surge in the number of patients in the last few months. This could be a positive sign as well, as it means more patients are coming forward for treatment.

Many people are questioning the suggestion of giving death penalty to peddlers to solve the problem at hand. Dr Debashish Basu said it is not easy to eradicate the drug problem from society and only a sustained effort will solve the problem. According to Dr Basu, focus of the efforts against drugs should be to first contain it.

A visit to the Punjab government’s District de-addiction and Rehabilitation Centre, Mohali, revealed that the number of drug patient coming for treatment has increased manifold in the last two years. Dr Anshu Garg, co-incharge of the centre said patients are taken care of well in the 50-bedded hospital cum rehabilitation centre.

“Patients are mostly in the age group of 20-30 years. There have been cases of even teenagers too coming for treatment. Each district has a de-addiction centre and this is the designated centre for the Mohali district. Treatment is comparatively cheap here-200 per day for treatment and stay and food. After a few days when the patients respond to treatment they are shifted to the rehabilitation centre here and are charged just 50 per day for all the facilities. The treatment goes for at least a month, but continues further also. The full treatment may take six months to one year.

The market rates for the same treatment and rehabilitation range from 1000 to 3,000 per day. Many people still prefer private treatment firstly because there is lack of trust on government doctors and secondly because they want to maintain strict privacy,” said Dr Garg. Rajendra Singh, one of the two attendants at the centre said there is shortage of staff and they are overworked as a result.

All the patients admitted at the district de-addiction centre are kept under lock and key and two people, including a policeman and an attendant guard the centre. No outsider is allowed to meet the patients. “We have to maintain these precautions to ensure drugs are not passed to the admitted patients. As long as they are here we have to be vigilant. There have been a number of relapses. There are cases where the patients came back for treatment for the third or the fourth time also,” Dr Garg said.

According to Jeevan Sandesh Foundation, Kharar, said they have a 9- bedded rehabilitation centre in Kharar and another centre in Delhi. “We are not into treatment. We are just a rehabilitation centre where we try to cure patients after medical treatment through counseling. There should be occupational therapies courses at the de-addiction and rehabilitation centres,‘’ it suggested.

“Patients come from both rich and poor class. We provide counseling. So far we have seen 150 people ‘cleaned’ in Delhi through counseling in the last three to five years. It means there has not been any relapse in as many cases,” said Raghubir Singh. He suggests that government de-addiction and rehabilitation centres must have courses in occupational therapies to motivate patients to take up some work, get busy instead of wandering around aimlessly and getting caught in the drug circle again.

Now, in a move to wean away addicts, Brahm Mohindra, Health and Family Welfare Minister Punjab said the state is aiming to provide government and private jobs to the youngsters who give up drugs after rehabilitation and training. But Yogeshwar Sharma of AAP pooh-poohed the idea. “When the government cannot even provide jobs to lakhs of fit candidates, how can it employ the `reformed druggists,” he said.

Punjab has vowed to get treatment for its employees taking drugs instead of treating them as criminals and taking action against them, according to Captain Amarinder. He has also promised free treatment for drug addicts from poor families.

Rising Cases Of Drug Deaths Point To The Dark Side Of ‘DEV BHOOMI’

On March 31, 17-year-old Subhash (name changed) from Dangoli village in Una district of Himachal Pradesh, died due to over dose of Chitta (Heroin). People in the locality strongly protested against the death, increasing cases of narcotics trade and inaction of the police against the culprits in the area. Few months earlier a youth in Haroli had also lost his life due to the same reason. In the last one year, at least four people have died due to the intake of narcotics in the state. Himachal Pradesh has the third highest rate of cases in the country under Narcotics Drug and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act, according to the recent report of National Crime Record Bureau (NCRB).

Only 310 cases reported in 2003 under NDPS were registered in the state. In 2014 ,the number reached 644. But the latest report of NCRB reveals that Himachal Pradesh, is now on third spot, with the total number of incidents per lakh population accounting for 13.1, with a total of 929 cases reported in the cognizable crimes under Special and Local Laws (SLL) crimes in NDPS Act 1985. A report by the “Himachal Watcher”, an NGO, said that NDPS cases in Himachal tripled in last 10 years.

The report said that “in Himachal Pradesh, the growing narcotics menace has taken over a large number of youths in Kullu, Manali, Mandi and Shimla. The narcotics trade is assuming a horrific shape in Kullu where large numbers of tourists, mostly Israelis, pour in every year. This has inspired local farmers to clandestinely cultivate illegal poppy or cannabis crops to earn quick bucks”.

According to Tehelka investigation, Manali, Kasol, Malana in Kullu districts are still the epicentre of narcotics trade. Rave parties are held in and around Malana by foreign nationals and local residents. Even there have been allegations that few of the foreign nationals are illegally (without valid permission from the government of India) staying in Malana area and they are involved in the drug trade with the help of locals. In the past seven years, over 82 foreign nationals, mainly Britons, Israelis, Dutch, Germans, Japanese and Italians, have been arrested under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act in the state.

Quoting a study by the Indira Gandhi Medical College and Hospital (IGMC), Shimla, a judgment by a Himachal Pradesh High Court Bench headed by Justice Rajiv Sharma had observed 40 per cent youth in the state are involved in drug abuse. Himachal High Court had recently pulled up the state functionaries on the issue and said that the destruction campaign was mere on papers after the state DGP had submitted in the court that around 400 villages in the state are affected with illegal cultivation of cannabis.

The DGP had told the court that under the campaign huge number of cannabis plants are destroyed by the police with the help of locals. The state government records show that there are 51,500 acres in Kullu Valley alone where cannabis is cultivated. Cannabis crops on 20,236 bighas of government land and 7,782 bighas of private land and 83,910 poppy plants were destroyed last year.

Recently, minor son of a former MLA was taken into custody along with his three friends in a drug case. The vehicle in which they were travelling was owned by the former legislator. On specific input, vehicle was intercepted in Mandi town and 500 gram of charas was seized from it. All four were taken into custody under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act. However, they were handed over to their parents later.

Interestingly, Chief Minister Jai Ram Thakur too admitted recently that about 27 per cent youth in Himachal Pradesh are involved in drug abuse and for making the state drug free it is important to take collective steps. He said, “Drug abuse is a social vice which needs to be curbed with people’s participation”. He told the Tehelka that a Special Task Force (STF) has been constituted to effectively campaign against the drug peddlers and three State Narcotics Crime Control units have been set up at Shimla, Kangra and Kullu.

Many feel that neighbouring state (Punjab) is badly affected by drugs and in Himachal too its menace is a serious challenge. “Our government has adopted zero tolerance towards narcotics. Whether it’s Malana or any other area that is known for growing opium or cannabis, the Jai Ram government is currently destroying their cultivation,” said state cabinet minister Govind Singh Thakur, who represents Manali constituency in the state assembly. During the police campaign from January 19 to February 1, 27.515 kgs of charas, 215 gms of opium, 38,279 kgs of poppy husk, 55.868 kgs of ganja, 37.175 gms of heroin and 19.83 gms of cociane was siezed by police and 66 Indians and seven Nepalese were arrested by the police.

This is a shocking fact that drug menace in Himachal had never been a major and serious issues in the assembly elections. Politicians also do not prefer to take the issue seriously in and outside the assembly. Senior Congress leader and an engineering graduate Rajesh Dharmani agrees that there is immence need to include this issue by the politicians in their speeches. “This is unfortunate that issue of this kind is not taken seriously. Time has come that we should save our children from drugs menace and we can play a major role in it,” he added.

Inaccessible valleys and lofty mountains in the western Himalayas are areas for cultivation of cannabis and opium. They are the country’s biggest drug-producing areas with a considerable quantity finding its way to Europe. The lure of drugs and quick bucks also attracts foreigners to the largely unexplored areas of Himachal Pradesh where they have become part of unorganised drug cultivation. It is alleged that few of them even never returned to their homes. Over 2,480 villages are dotted across inaccessible areas in Kullu, Chamba, Mandi, Shimla and Sirmaur districts, known for growing cannabis and poppy cultivation.

Police records show that there are about 51,500 acres in Kullu Valley alone where cannabis is cultivated. Areas in the state bordering Punjab and Haryana have become drug hubs. The drug menace has assumed alarming proportions in pilgrim centres and tourist destinations too. A former state ADGP, KC Sadyal, while talking to Tehelka revealed that over 58 per cent of the poppy and cannabis produce in Himachal Pradesh is smuggled out to countries like Israel, Italy, Holland and some other European countries. “The remaining finds its way to Nepal or Indian states like Goa, Punjab and Delhi, he added. Malana is well known for cultivating the prized hashish, a purified resinous extract of cannabis which is known as “Malana Cream” among the people involved in its illegal business. McLeodganj and its surrounding areas in Kangra district are the other epicentres of the illegal narcotics trade in the state. Sadyal said, “Alternative farming (cultivation of exotic vegetables and flowers) is the only way of controlling poppy and cannabis cultivation.”

A report published recenlty said that “state was earlier known for drugs like marijuana which was grown in the hills and consumed by foreigners, however, now the availability of synthetic drugs and entry of notorious chitta (heroine) has become a cause of concern for the state’s law enforcing agencies. Apart from these, MDMA commonly known as ecstasy and liquid lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD), are also in circulation and the youngsters are hooked to a whole lot of pharmaceutical drugs like cough syrups, anti-depressants and sleep-inducing pills which are affordable on account of their low cost”. Drug smuggling has now become a multi-dimensional problem in the state as foreigners, locals and now smugglers from other states of the country resorting to barter of synthetic drugs for hashish or marijuana. It is an open secret that marijuana and hashish have been grown, consumed and smuggled out of Himachal for decades. Now, the drug mafia has grown to an enormous size and the influx of synthetic drugs and abuse of pharmaceutical drugs pose a big challenge, the report said.

Himachal Watcher, an NGO in its recent report said that sadly, far more than its outstanding geography, people and culture, the tourist influx reveals a deadly narcotic nexus. An increasing number of localities are falling prey to this business and addiction. The representatives of Bombay Hemp Company had in October 2017 called on Governor Devvrat at Rajbhawan and gave a presentation on utilising Industrial Hemp as a strategic asset devoted to a reformation of agriculture and boosting its role in the economy alongwith uplifting socio-economic standards of local farmers. “The genetically modified hemp will possess only 0.3 to 1 per cent potency as compared to 3 to 4 per cent found in the currently cultivated plant.  Apparently, these plants will be of no use to the drug users”.

Action plan

A comprehensive destruction campaign against the cultivation of opium poppy has been launched from April 15 in all the districts of the state. Giving details of the action plan being undertaken during the campaign, the Director General of Police, Sita Ram Mardi, informed that all revenue and forest officials, elected representatives of Panchayati Raj bodies, and urban local bodies are duty bound under section 47 of NDPS Act, 1985, to inform police about the illegal cultivation of cannabis and opium-poppy in their respective area of jurisdiction. They will give the information in writing to concerned SHO and to Superintendent of Police. The forest officials to patrol in their respective jurisdiction and report the illegal cultivation in their beat to the police.

According to Mardi ,once illegal cultivation is detected, a joint campaign will be launched to destroy such cultivation by involving all stakeholders, enforcement agencies such as police, NCB, SNCB, CID and departments of Forests, Revenue, Panchayati Raj and Rural Development. “These agencies will submit a progress report on poppy, opium and cannabis destruction before August 15, 2018. All SPs will associate with Mahila Mandals, Yuvak Mandals and other NGOs while conducting the destruction of opium poppy and cannabis crops,” he added.

He told that Agriculture and Horticulture departments in coordination with Rural Development department jointly will submit a proposal to adopt alternative cash crops suitable for areas cultivating opium poppy and cannabis illegally. Training module for Nodal training Officers of Education department to sensitise students on drug abuse will be prepared. During PTA and SMC meetings, parents of students will also be sensitised on this issue. He said that counselling sessions are also being organised once in a week in educational institutions on drug abuse. “The major objective of such counselling is to reach the supplier of drugs through students,” he added.

The state police chief said that all shops/dhabas located near educational institutions be kept under strict surveillance and their inspection be carried out time to time and suspicious activities around these institutions will be informed to the police. Public Relations Department will run a massive awareness programme through different methodologies including street plays on the ill effects of drug abuse. However, street play team of Ist IRBn Bangarh Una has already set into action. The health department will share publicity material of drug abuse on 104 helplines with Education and Public Relations departments for further dissemination among the public.

The State Health Department has also started a De-Addiction Programme, as one of the main component of Rashtriya Kishore Swasthya Karyakram (RKSK). Under this programme, de-addiction centres have been made functional in all regional and zonal hospitals of the state. One clinical psychologists and one medical social worker are appointed in all these Centres. These clinical psychologists and medical social workers are also imparted training for this job at National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences (NIMHANS), Bangaluru. These Counsellors also conduct at least four field visits in a month in different institutions for IEC activities.

HIMACHAL WOMEN LEAD HEMP DESTROY CAMPAIGN

Himachal women have played a crucial role in the Bhang Ukhado Abhiyan (Hemp Destroy Campaign). More than 80 Mahila Mandals in the state are involved in this campaign. Kamla Devi, member of Mahila Mandal in Kullu district said that women are the most effected community in the society due to increasing narcotics habit among the men and male youth. She said that once caught in the habit of drugs, their husbands or sons stop taking care of the families. “yeh log apne liye nashe ka jugaad karne men lage rehte hain. unkee sehat ka bhee isse satyanash ho gaya hai and isse ham mahilaaon par ghar chalane ka baujh bad gaya hai (The men keep busy in managing drugs for them and do not take care of family problems. This have also destroyed their health and hence we women have to take all the work load), she added. Another member Satyawati from Sirmaur district said that women are actively participating the Bhang Ukhado Abhiyan. This has helped the police to destroy hemp in the remote areas of Kullu. Yuvak Mandals are also been roped in for the job.

letters@tehelka.com

FIFA World Cup 2018: French Toast But Cheers For Croatia!

Image Credit FIFA

So France has lifted the coveted World Cup for the second time in style as a 4-2 victory over Croatia in a most dramatic and entertaining match. Indeed the big guns of France delivered on the biggest stage when it mattered the most. After an early own goal by Mario Mandzukic, Paul Pogba and Kylian Mbappe hit the target. Ivan Perisic and Mandzukic replied for Croatia, but could not change the fortunes of France. Another highlight of the match was that it was the highest scoring decider since England beat West Germany way back in 1966 by 4-2. However, in the end it was the statistic that favoured Ferance who have become the World champions for the second time after an earlier win on home soil in 1998.

France is now on the top of the world with some as young as just 19. They preserved their right state of mind and showed mental and psychological strength till the end of the tournament. Croatia had more of the ball, about 61 per cent more to be specific, and showed good energy but went behind in the 18th minute because of the own goal. Then came the moment which may keep the VAR debate at the top of sport’s agenda.  Perisic flapped an arm at a corner and ignoring Croatian protests, Griezmann stroked the ball home in the 38th minute for his fourth goal of Russia 2018. That made it the highest-scoring first half since the World Cup 1974. But there was more to come. Croatia were on top again after the break but France went 3-1 up on the hour as Mbappe and Griezmann combined to set up Pogba on the edge of the box.  Six minutes later Mbappe, the 19-year-old young player of the tournament claimed his fourth goal in Russia and became the first teenager to score in a final since the great Pele himself in 1958. After successive attempts, the chances of Croatia striking back again looked almost impossible but they were given a lifeline by French goalkeeper, Lloris, who tried to dribble round Mandzukic only for the striker to block the ball and send it into the unguarded net. They continued fighting, refusing to accept defeat and continued making forays, which unfortunately for their fans didn’t lead to any more goals. Croatia, beaten by the French in the 1998 semi-finals in their first World Cup appearance, continued to press but their energy was sapped and France held out.  Croatia’s fans saluted and cheered their heroes while torrential rain lashed down on the presentation ceremony. 

As Croatian Coach said, “We are sad but proud at the same time,” he said. “We played well but the penalty knocked the wind out of us and after that it was very difficult. We have been dignified in our victories and we must be in defeat as well.” Indeed the Croatian team had defied odds to reach the final.

“We were all sad and downcast after the game ended. But, I told them to hold their heads high and be proud of their display. Sometimes in football you lose, but you need to be dignified in defeat too,” the coach said. Indeed while France has won the cup, the toast is for Croatia.

Stealing childhood: Factories illegally make kids work for peanuts

Photo credit: Bachpan Bachao Andolan

It was almost noon for the team that was waiting at the District Magistrate’s office in Shastri Nagar, east Delhi, for permission to carry out a rescue-raid operation. This wasn’t a usual event. Nobody in the team had any clue as to where they were heading except for the fact that they all have gathered for a common mission-rescue the children illegally labouring in factories, shops, and other places.

Soon, the child labour raid-rescue operation began. Split into four groups, they dispersed in the congested, narrow lanes of the Shastri Nagar locality, mostly in residential addresses with karkhanas (factories) running in secret in the backyard with the unmanned workforce, mostly minors from Bihar. These karkhanas mostly deal with embroidery, zari and jewellery work and are found to involve boys as young as eight years old.

The factories and shops caught a whiff of the mission and the children were asked to run hither-thither to escape the eyeballs of the rescue team. The team managed to rescue only 12 boys. “Sigh! Yahan jab bhi raid karo factory walo ko pehle hi pata chal jata hai (the factory owners get a whiff of our plan whenever we raid here),” Arshad, who was leading the operation, told Tehelka.

The team had to face the ire of an agitated crowd led by a group of factory owners. The angry crowd not only stopped the rescue team from proceeding but also threatened them and the District Magistrate, who was part of the operation with dire consequences. It was a lucky escapade from witnessing any untoward incident.

On June 26, almost 12 personnel accompanying the team of Kailash Satyarthi Children’s Foundation took out a child labour raid-rescue operation in Shastri Nagar, east Delhi. It was the second day of the operation. Joining the team of Kailash Satyarthi Children’s Foundation was RED FM India, which partnered with them for #Bajaoforacause, the District Magistrate, K Mahesh, and Tehelka.

Boys’ narratives

The 11-year-old Aakash (name changed) hesitantly showed the deep cut mark on his right hand, an injury he endured while working at a juice shop in east Delhi. Initially, the boy refused to answer on being asked the details about his cut mark. But when he was assured that nothing of that sort will happen in future, he revealed that he left his job at the shop as the owner would often hit him for petty mistakes, sometimes barehanded, and other times with any object he could get hold of.

“Pehle wala malik bohut bura insaan tha. Roz marta tha, har baat par…jo bhi haat mein aata tha uthake mardeta tha. Tabhi waha kaam chod diya  (My former master was a cruel person. He would hit me over every small thing and with any object that came handy. That’s why I left the work there),” said Aakash.

Another victim Vijay (name changed), who hails from Darbhanga district in Bihar, landed in east Delhi three months back to work at a local Chinese fast food shop as a cook. The 15-year-old would labour for 10 hours (12pm-10pm) with no break or week off and did not receive a single penny from his owner (at the time of meeting him).

The 13-year-old Sonu (name changed), a class VIII dropout from Purnia district in Bihar said that he would share the room with 9-10 other mates in a tiny, cramped space, all working as helpers or wage labourers in a garment shop in east Delhi.   

Aakash, Vijay and Sonu were three of the 12 boys rescued on June 12 in child labour rescue-raid operation led by Kailash Satyarthi Children’s Foundation and RED FM India. Tehelka, which was part of the mission, had a chance to interact with the boys.

The inquiry revealed that 11 boys were from Bihar and Uttar Pradesh had been brought to Delhi in last two-three months.

Districts like Darbhanga and Purnia in Bihar and Dahria and Badaun in Uttar Pradesh have most of their boys engaged in child labour in India’s capital. One of the boys was found to have arrived on the very day of the rescue operation. The team also discovered that almost every day one to two boys from remote parts of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh land in the mini trade areas of Shastri Nagar.

Even though various studies show that there has been a dramatic fall in the child labour in the last two decades, eliminating child labour is still an unabating and an arduous task in India. Despite so many policies in place, around 80 per cent children are still bereft of their rights – education, health, and basic socio-economic conditions and risk losing their future and talent to illegal activities.  

Child Labour Act

In July 2016, the Parliament had passed the Child Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2016. This Act prohibits employment of children in 83 hazardous occupations and processes. The Act defined “adolescent” as the children between 14 to 18 years of age and bars their employment in any hazardous occupations.

The Act clearly states that employing children below 14 years will attract a jail term between 6 months to two years or a penalty between twenty-thousand to fifty thousand rupees or both. Repeat offenders attract imprisonment between 1 year to 3 years (6 months to 2 years). 

On the occasion of World Day Against Child Labour on June 12, 2018, both Kailash Satyarthi Children’s Foundation and RED FM India, came together to carry forward the noble mission of child protection. 

Noble Laureate Kailash Satyarthi who was quoted as saying to RED FM: “Radio was a tool for my activism when I started my fight against child labour. Radio as a broadcast medium has a far-reaching impact and the ability to reach out to the most remote areas. I am happy that the message of Safe Childhood could reach the masses.”

RJ Raunac from RED FM India said, “I was recently part of a live rescue raid and believe me the children who were rescued from there are in dire need of the basic necessities of life. They were hungry and deprived of basic clothes. I am very sure that Kailash Satyarthi foundation will give a meaning to their life and will look after their education.  

At the moment the boys are being taken care of at Mukti Ashram, the rehabilitation centre of Bachpan Bachao Andolan (BBA) by Kailash Satyarthi foundation.

Action, not politics, will help curb drug deaths

In Punjab, June had proved to be the cruellest month as dozens of deaths were reported from different parts of the State due to drugs overdose. Drug addiction, interestingly, was a major issue in the last Assembly elections in Punjab. Both Congress and Aam Aadmi Party had taken on the then ruling Shiromani Akali Dal and the Bharatiya Janta Party on this issue. So much so, a Cabinet Minister in the SAD-BJP government had been trolled for his alleged involvement in the drug addiction problem in the state. During his campaign and later after taking over reins of power in Punjab, Capt Amarinder Singh-led Congress government had promised last year to wipe out drugs from Punjab. But the situation seems to have further worsened. Punjab Health Minister Brahm Mohindra, however, dismissed the toll figure as highly exaggerated and claimed that “only two drug-overdose deaths were confirmed as per official records”.

Media reports suggest that the first two weeks witnessed 17 deaths. In other words, one life snuffed out every passing day. Kuljeet Singh of Sawaddi Kalan village in Jagraon sub division of Ludhiana died on June 29 due to drug overdose. His body was cremated on July 2. Police found a spoon, a cigarette lighter and a syringe near the body, which was apparent evidence that he was doing drugs before he died. His wife Harpreet informed that her husband was admitted to a private de-addiction center in Rasoolra village in Khanna for more than two months and was discharged on June 21. On the fateful night, he went out of the house for the first time after being discharged from the centre. His mother Hardeep Kaur confirmed that he used ‘chitta’ (white powder).

Jotu of Gumtala in Amritsar too died due to drug addiction. His father Amar Singh told police that drug peddlers were quite active in the village. “I knew that he was addicted to alcohol, but I don’t know when he got into the narcotics.” Gurbhej Singh of village Dhotian in Tarn Taran district died on June 25. His mother Sawinder Kaur said that her son was a drug addict. “Drugs have snatched him away from us forever and I found a syringe of drugs still in his vein when he died.”

Lavpreet of Talwandi Sabo in Bathinda died on June 30. His father Jeevan Khana confirmed that “Lavpreet got hooked to drugs about two years back after he came in contact with some bad elements and used to take chitta”. In Kotkapura under Faridkot district, Balwinder Singh died on June 22. When his body was found from fields, a syringe was still in his hands. Saurav and Nitin died in Jalandhar due to drug addiction. They were lying unconscious in Amar Nagar. Police recovered drug injections and some other banned substances near the bodies.

Sukhjinder Singh of Fatehabad in Tarn Taran district died on June 6 due to drug-overdose. His wife told that “earlier he used to only drink, but after coming in contact with some smugglers of Fatehabad and Goindwal Sahib, he started taking drugs”. She said that his body was found in the house of a smuggler in Goindwal Sahib, “with a syringe still in his vein”.

Kamal Kant Maheshwari of Rama in Bathinda died on June 10 due to drug overdose. Shivam of Ferozepur died on July 1. His father Ashok Kumar said that his son was an assistant mechanic in an auto shop where he fell into bad company. “Initially, he was taking tablets, but later became addicted to ‘chitta’”. Basant Singh of Khai Pheme village in Ferozepur got trapped into the drug menace and stated taking “injections”, said the family.

‘CUT’ DEATHS

Investigations by the police have revealed that it is the deadly cocktail of adulterated heroin mixed with other substances, called “cut” in local parlance that is proving to be deadly to drug addicts in Punjab. There is unprecedented fear in families that the ‘cut’ is causing. ‘Cut’ is not a new drug, but an adulterated form of heroin. It is like injecting cement in one’s body. It reacts so fast that the victim can’t even take out the syringe and dies instantly. DGP Suresh Arora said, “All IGs, DIGs of ranges and CPs have been asked to probe each of the recent cases. The police will work closely with the Health Department as well as civil society groups in the field of de-addiction and rehabilitation of drug addicts.They have been directed to act against drug smugglers to choke the supply chain.”

Faced with criticism from several quarters over alleged spate of deaths due to drug overdose in the state, the Punjab cabinet has decided to recommend to the Centre death penalty for drug peddlers and smugglers. The decision was taken at a meeting of the Cabinet, chaired by Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh, which resolved to send a formal recommendation soon to the Union Government to this effect, according to an official spokesperson. The chief minister had called for the meeting to discuss the issue, particularly in the context of the recent spate of deaths due to alleged drug overdose and adulterated drugs in the state.

The Cabinet decided to constitute a special working group under the chairmanship of Additional Chief Secretary (Home) NS Kalsi to review and monitor, on a day-to-day basis, the action being taken to check and control drug abuse. The special working group constituted to review and update the government strategy against drugs will have ACS (Health), DGP (Law & Order), DGP (Intelligence) and ADGP (STF) as members. A cabinet sub-committee has also been formed under the chairmanship of the chief minister, with the special working group mandated to report directly to it. Health and Social Security Ministers have been appointed members of the sub-committee which will meet once a week to take stock of the situation and review the progress of the anti-drug campaign of the government.

The AAP and SAD have hit out at the Congress regime for allegedly failing to fulfil its pre-poll promise of curbing drug menace in the state within four weeks of coming to power. Amarinder Singh has also ordered a probe into the recent spate of drug-related deaths in the state and directed officials to take action against culprits.

 STAFF DOPE TEST

The chief minister has announced that all employees of the Punjab Government would have to undergo a dope test every year. Leader of AAP, the principal opposition party in Punjab sent a letter to Amarinder Singh suggesting him to review the controversial dope test order as it could shift the political discourse from the burning issue of police-drug mafia nexus. The letter said that “feeling the pinch many government employee unions have demanded dope test of the political class of the state as well. In order to avoid social stigma many political leaders including Ministers, MLAs, etc. have made a beeline to get their dope tests done. As such the focus of debate has shifted from the real issue of drug mafia having deep connections with the police officers of the state, to a non-issue of dope test”.

The recent tweet by CM Capt Amarinder Singh said, “I have ordered @PunjabPolice DGP to probe all recent drug related deaths and to take exemplary action against anyone found responsible for the deaths of these innocent youths. Government will also assist the affected families in rehabilitation” .

Punjab that successfully brought in Green Revolution, then fought against terrorism, seems to be trying hard to fight a successful battle against drugs.

POLITICS RULES

Strangely, nobody in the political furore created over these deaths bothered to ponder over the question as to how the neighbourhood, family, police, local political workers, leaders of all hues failed to notice and report when victims were alive and in the grip of menace. Noise was made only over the dead bodies. Statements were made castigating the ruling party and the government.

In what is essentially a problem that has roots in the individual behaviour, social milieu and economy, a collective response from society and its organs of governance is what is required to take the problem head on. There seems consensus on this but,
unfortunately, politics takes the front seat. Recently, Akali Dal offered of a combined strategy was outrightly rejected by the government. On the other hand, elected representatives are undergoing dope tests only to show political one-upmanship.  

“Community involvement is must for containing the alarming problem which sadly has not happened till now, said Dr SS Johl, a Ludhiana-based agricultural economist of international repute. He is part of a civil society group which organised peaceful demonstrations all over the state in the first week of July in the wake of recent deaths.” Our role is complementary to the government of the day. We are motivating, encouraging people to take stand against drugs not the government in order to get over the problem,” he added.

For one thing, the police and experts’ explanation of recent deaths as fallout of choked drugs supply chain after the STF launched crackdown on drug suppliers sounds plausible though the Opposition is unimpressed for its own reasons. This mutual political mistrust is the real undoing.  The people at grassroot are availing the government facilities of de-addiction and rehabilitation as the numbers show. New initiatives like Drug Abuse Prevention Officers (DAPO) and Neighbourhood Buddy to lend emotional healing touch and prevent stagmatisation the addict have been launched.  The state’s educational institutions have been roped in for awareness. Yet, the short-sighted politics fuels public mistrust.

NO QUICK SOLUTION

There cannot be quick solution to the problem as it has not cropped up overnight. About 30 years ago in Punjab, Opium was consumed predominantly in village but consumers were doing fine as they were mostly rich ones. Poppy husk was its cheaper alternative and did no life-threatening harm to its consumers on good numbers. In the second phase, about 20 years or so later, the younger lot started taking “medical nasha” as part of which they used to take drugs for medicinal purposes like cough syrups, capsules as well as some concoctions in large quantities to get high.

Heroin or white powder (chitta) which is derived from Opium in a laboratory arrived on the scene about 15 years ago. Around this time, the farming in Punjab started becoming increasingly less remunerative incidentally, the state witnessed real estate boom. The prices of agricultural lands and those around cities and town shot up. Due to this, initially the youth had the money to afford this costly addiction of chitta. Over a period of time, this boom subsided and this addicted set of youth became small drug peddlers selling very small quantities of either one gram, five grams to earn money to survive addiction. Over 18000 arrests made in Punjab comprise mostly of these small peddlers.

Experts are of the view that the government and society must realize that the addiction has been there since times immemorial. Time has come to think out of box rising above political interests to contain the menace through pragmatic measures. “In the present situation, the only choice is how much of which addiction the society wants to have at a particular phase in time and that choice is relative at best. From that perspective it makes sense to liberalise milder intoxicants. The government must take along communities to combat the problem,” suggested Prof. AK Kala, a leading psychaitirst who runs two hospitals in Ludhiana offering acute care and long term care of addicts.

NEW POLICIES SET TO INJECT HEALTH AMONG DRUG ADDICTS

Scores have died of drug overdose in various parts of Punjab in recent past. While the present administration is blaming the previous state government for its inaction to deal with the drug addiction and related threats to the society, the latter is questioning the apathy of the existing setup for it. PUNJAB HEALTH MINISTER BRAHM MOHINDRA discusses the issue with RAJU WILLIAM and tells him what measures the government has taken so far to handle the drug menace.

There is huge furore over recent deaths due to drugs. Your government had pledged to wipe out the menace in four weeks of coming to power. As the state health minister and senior-most cabinet minister, what is your take on this?

See, this is a big and complex issue. There are social and psychological factors involved. It is there for quite some years as apparently little was done by the previous government. We have set up a Special Task Force which choked the supply chain. Some anti-social elements seem to be taking advantage of such situation by indulging in supply of some deadly mixture to victims of substance abuse which is proving fatal.

How many officially confirmed drug-related deaths have been reported till date in the state?

Neither the state health department nor the police have any data of such deaths for last 10 years. The reason may be that families do not normally report fearing social stigma.

You said that the supply chain has been choked, but the people hooked to substance abuse need a proper reform mechanism once the supply is stopped. Is your department equipped to handle such victims?

Yes, this is absolutely a very valid question. We all know once the supply is stopped to any drug abuse victim requires an immediate rehabilitation system. We have already put in place a robust system of medical facilities, completely based on a new revised approach recommended by leading psychiatrists of global repute.

What is the new approach to rehabilitate the substance abusers?

As soon as we came to power, we studied the models of various countries affected by drugs and the strategies adopted by them. As guided by our CM, experts’ opinions were taken to prepare rehabilitation strategy in the form of a completely new mechanism Outpatient Opioid Assisted Treatment (OOAT) launched by our government.

What is an OOAT clinic?

It is an OPD-based clinic with trained manpower. The department followed the need-based approach that required people only with severe problem to be admitted in the in-patient facilities whereas others can be treated in OPD facility. The psychiatrist of the district is its overall in-charge. Here a patient is examined by the Psychiatrist or Medical Officer trained for de-addiction. This program was launched in pilot phase in Amritsar, Moga and Tarn Taran districts in October 2017 and later extended to rest of the state in May 2018.

How do you respond to the allegation not all OOAT centres are functional due to lack of facilities especially the shortage of medicines?

This is absolutely wrong allegation. We have 81 OOAT centres functional across all the districts, which are running successfully. There are total 8,121 patients in OOAT clinics, out of which 6,897 patients are re-visiting, which means a very high retention rate of 84.93 per cent. Total 2,71,098 people have availed this OPD service and provided 8,02,295 Buprenorphine tablets which is the key medicine.

With this new strategy in place, will your government close down de-addiction and rehabilitation centres?

No, rather we have strengthened the existing centres and renamed them as NavJeevan Kendras and NavNirman Kendras so that stigma of being addict does not stick. We are running five model 50-bed de-addiction centres having a qualified Counsellor complete availability of all important medicines including Buprenorphine- naloxone and Tramadol. Besides 32 government centres at district and sub-division hospitals, there are around 96 10-bed private centers licensed by the government. There are 22 rehabilitation centres working where patients go after detoxification at de-addiction centres.

What do you think could help reverse the deadly trend?

Emotional touch, I believe, can really help wean back the victims from drugs besides community awareness up to the grass root level. We are launching a major campaign involving interpersonal communication, mass media and social media to combat the menace.

PUNJAB POLICE GET TOUGH ON DRUG ABUSERS

Punjab Director General of Police SURESH ARORA recently issued strict directives to the field officers to step up their crackdown on the activities of gangsters and drug smugglers, making it clear that they would be held accountable for any activity of drugs smuggling in their areas. Arora discusses with RAJU WILLIAM his plans to curb drugs menace in the state.

The state police are under fire over complicity of its officials in drug trade. What’s your reaction to the charge? 

Yes, there have been instances of police officials in such cases but strict action has been taken. Recently a Deputy Superintendent of Police was dismissed from service. Also, action was initiated against some SHOs too. But let me tell you such instances are an aberration in the police force comprising 75,000 employees.

Cases have come to light where smugglers/peddlers lodged in jails are running drug trade from inside. What is being done to break their nexus outside?

The only way to tackle this problem is to cut off communication of drug convicts with their outside links. For this, a high security jail is coming up at Bathinda having capacity to lodge 1500 inmates mostly involved in drug trade as well as hardened criminals. It will have all the high-tech security equipment including jammers. The state government has also requisitioned two companies of Central Industrial Security Force to control access to eight jails in the state.

What is the exact number of smugglers/peddlers arrested and narcotic substance seized since new government came to power in 2017?

Total 17,094 cases were registered under NDPS Act and 18,977 persons arrested between March 2017 and June 2018. This shows the massive offensive launched against the drugs in the state. There is not let up in this offensive.

Given the recent spate of drug-related deaths, do you think challenges for police on drugs front have increased?

To talk about challenges, this is what police are for, always scaling those at hand and preparing for the new ones. Here I would also say even a single death is unfortunate. We have been able to choke the drugs supply line but I must say that is not enough. The demand has also to be reduced. Due to difficulty in procuring drugs, addicts are resorting to other synthetic drugs and concoctions through injections which are proving fatal. So, all the state agencies are focusing on reduction of demand through awareness campaigns and effective de-addiction, rehabilitation measures. We have also decided to register cases under section 304 of the IPC so that cases of drug-related deaths are investigated comprehensively from all angles.

How do you rate the performance of the Special Task Force (STF) against drugs set up in 2017?

I would say the STF has done well but still there is scope to do a lot more with additional resources and experience since it was set up as a dedicated body only a year ago to meet challenges of drugs. After review, the government has decided to bring it under the purview of the state police. The formal notification is under consideration. The Drug Abuse Prevention Officer (DAPO) programme under it is expected to generate a lot of awareness among people in coming time.

Since there is consensus on need of community involvement in dealing with drugs problems. What initiatives the Punjab police have taken in this direction?

Police primarily need to create confidence in the community that instead of punitive action, it will facilitate treatment of addicts. We intend to resume the practice of village level visits by police officer for the purpose. During my tenure as the DGP under the previous government, we had covered over 25,000 villages. I also visited villages along with my officers. Another important aspect to achieve the purpose is that there is zero tolerance towards corruption at the police station level. Also Helpline 181 is there for people for drug-related information and tips. All details about addicts are kept confidential. We are also starting awareness campaign to reach out to youths in educational institutions right from school level.

CM ASSURES END TO DRUG ABUSE IN PUNJAB

Estimates vary but by some accounts as many as two-thirds of households in Punjab have a drug addict in their midst. Prisons in the state are overcrowded with drug-users and peddlers. Streets and farms too witness the easy availability of narcotics and opiates. Last year the government arrested 18,977 peddlers and treated some two lakh addicts. PUNJAB CHIEF MINISTER AMARINDER SINGH discusses with RAJU WILLIAM his action plan to save the state from the clutches of drug abuses.

Any change in your perspective on handling of drugs issue in the state since you took over its reins 15 months ago?

I don’t know what you mean by change in perspective. If anything, my resolve to wipe out the menace and save our kids from drugs has strengthened further. These drug smugglers and peddlers have ruined our state and our future generation. I will not let this continue, come what may. This is a promise I made to myself before the Assembly elections and I stick by it.

Major allegation by the Opposition is that big fish in drugs trade still out of net. Is it so?

Some have fled the country, but they are on our radar, and the STF and state police, along with other state and central government agencies, are pursuing them. I have made it clear to them — chase these criminals to the other corner of the world, if need be, but I want them back to face punishment for their deeds. We will not allow them to go scot-free. We owe this to ourselves, and more importantly to our children.

It is being alleged that the wings STF set up for the purpose are clipped and it’s not being allowed to get at bottom of the drug trade. Your take on this?

There is no question of clipping their wings. I had set up STF with the single-minded purpose of breaking the backbone of drugs. And for this, I gave them a free hand, which they used the power to the fullest to bring the drug mafia to its knees and push drugs out of the reach of our youth. Recently, we decided to bring them under the purview of the Punjab Police to enable them to have recourse to all the manpower and other resources that are at the disposal of the force. However, they will still continue to operate as an independent agency – like the Vigilance or the Intelligence bureaus. Their mandate is clear — they have to get to the bottom of this drug trade come what may, and ensure that Punjab becomes drug-free, once and for all.

How do you think your ideas of death penalty to first time offenders; mandatory dope test could make difference?

More than anything, I feel these will become deterrents for those tempted by the easy money to take on drug trading. They will know that even one mistake, or one step in the direction of drugs, will led them to the gallows. The message will go down loud and clear — this is too serious a crime for us to allow you even one deviation from the law. I am sure this will instil a sense of fear in the minds of prospective drug criminals. As for the mandatory dope test, it will convey that anyone doing drugs, even for fun, will stand to lose their chances of getting a job, in the first place, or being obstructed in their career progression. I know these are strong measures but then the situation, in my opinion, merits strong steps.

The recent responses of your government are being seen more as defensive after the issue returned to focus due to recent spate of deaths. Do you apprehend losing political ground?

Do you call death penalty or mandatory dope test defensive measures? Definitely, the recent spate of drug deaths prompted our decisions. But, let me make it clear, these decisions are not defensive. Rather they are among the sternest measures any government can take to tackle such a heinous problem, short of the kind of summary punishments doled out in certain countries.

Your government’s action plan since coming to power reportedly resulted in arrests of over 18,000 drug peddlers; treatment of over 2 lakh addicts. Still what do you think is lacking?

You’ve yourself given the numbers. Going by these numbers, the one thing that is definitely not lacking is the will to wipe out the menace. Resources were lacking for the STF and since our financial situation did not permit us to make the same available to them, we decided to put the resources of our police force at their disposal. Nothing, I repeat, nothing will be allowed to come between my government’s resolve and elimination of the drug problem.

 How do you view the way Opposition is flagging the issue?

How are they flagging it? It is the Congress, led by Rahul Gandhi, which flagged the issue three years ago. The Opposition is the one which has been responsible for the mess in the first place.

The Akalis, by their active or passive connivance, allowed the drug mafia to flourish in the 10 years of their rule. As far as AAP is concerned, there have been several cases and allegations of some of their top leaders in Punjab being involved in drugs. What they are now doing is trying to take political mileage from the issue. It’s sad that the Opposition is trying to exploit such a serious and sensitive issue to their advantage.

letters@tehelka.com

Farmers no gainers in Minimum Support Price hike

There is no gainsaying that the farmers will benefit if the Minimum Support Price, that acts as a benchmark for the determination of commodity price in the open market, is hiked and implemented; however, there are many dimensions to this declaration.

The recent announcement of the revision of Minimum Support Price of 14 kharif crops for the Kharif Marketing Season (KMS) 2018-19 by the Government of India grabbed headlines recently. The issue is of paramount significance, not because it affects farmers, the producers of food grains (rather they occupy the lowest slot in the hierarchy while deciding on redistribution of national income among the economic agents) but suits the incumbent political alliance, which is gearing up to face General Elections next year and assembly elections prior to that in states of Chhattisgarh, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh; having a sizable rural vote bank.

It is not only the farmer who gains or loss in case the commodity prices fetch decent returns; it is the entire value chain in the production, distribution and marketing of agriculture commodities that derive benefit from this.

The metrics of Minimum Support Price, its implementation, scope, leakages, alternatives, economic repercussions, and electoral gains and so on can be evaluated from the perspectives of different stakeholders.

Among all the variables, crucial in the food production and management in our country of 130 million people, farmers occupy the most important position.

So let’s start with farmers- their struggle for right to remunerative price and the occasional responses of the respective governments –that too to earn political mileage to woo the electorate.

The rural households, predominantly engaged in agriculture and allied activities, are politically and economically important and can catapult the fortunes of political parties.

According to year 2011 census, of the 121 crore Indians, 83.3 crore (68.84 per cent) live in hinterland while 37.7 crore stay in urban areas. These figures make it clear why the rural voters become apple of eyes for the political parties during the election countdown. In the current situation, the massive losses faced by the Bhartiya Janata Party in Lok Sabha and Assembly by-polls held during May this year took wind out of sails of BJP that had not recovered from the shock of dismal outcome of the Gujarat Assembly elections held in December 2017.

The weaning popularity among the rural voters is a major cause of worry for the ruling BJP alliance. At the same time, the nationwide agitations by the farmers’ organisations in different parts of the country on the growing rural distress and delay in implementation of Swaminathan Commission recommendations is a precursor to the surging discontent and dejection among the farming community.

Farmers in India might be poor and uneducated but understand well that BJP alliance is dragging its heels on Swaminathan Commission’s Report. The revised prices of the crops declared on July 4 still fall short of 50 per cent above the cost of production (A2+FL) in many cases.

Of the 14 crops-paddy, cotton, bajra, maize, ragi, tur,moong, urad, sunflower seed, groundnut, soyabean, sesamum, nigerseed, jowar- bajra would fetch an MSP close to C2+50 per cent criterion as the MSP had been hiked by 525 per quintal yielding a return of 96.5 per cent over cost. The highest per centage increase in MSP over previous years is for ragi (52.47 per cent) followed by jowar hybrid (42.94 per cent).

The MSP of paddy (Common) that is expected to cover maximum number of farmers has been revised by 200 per quintal (from 1550 per quintal last year to 1750 per quintal in KMS 2018-19) close to 13 per cent; far below to match the rhetoric on doubling the farmers’ income. The cost of cultivation calculated by the government agencies has also been debatable because the progressive agriculture practised in the north-west of India (Punjab, Haryana and Western Uttar Pradesh) is not comparable to the traditional cultivation in eastern states of Orissa, West Bengal and Chattisgarh. The cost of cultivation is far higher in some states and the farmers do not feel adequately compensated for their crops.

The long-awaited announcement of the government near the completion of its tenure has brought some respite to the farmers but the uncanny prevails. Jagtar Singh Brar, a farmer from village Mehma Serja, district Bhathinda, told that he sold his moong crop last week for `4,600 per quintal against the MSP (KMS 2017-18) of 6,161 per quintal at a grain market in Jagraon near Ludhiana. The revised price of Moong (KMS 2018-19) is 6,975. “Who will give us as per the revised MSP when we are not getting even the last year’s MSP?” He has no hope to earn remunerative price on crops other than wheat and paddy as the procurement system is fragile. Brar laments that he chose to pursue agriculture over a lucrative job after completing his post-graduation. He pursued agriculture with a passion but his income level has been dwindling; at the same time, his peers in other professions have a regular income with a growth graph year-on-year. The rate of land lease has to go through the roof and those who cultivate on leased land find it difficult to sustain.

Most of the farmers interviewed told that their experiments with horticulture crops and diversifying to cereals met with a complete failure as there are no takers at the remunerative prices. Nafed (National Agriculture Cooperative Marketing Federation of India) does not have the wherewithal to procure the produce and state government agencies are apathetic.

Ajayvir Jhakhar, a strong proponent of farmers’ welfare and Chairman of Bhartiya Krishak Samaj told that MSP is not a panacea for the sufferings of farmers. While he agrees that the MSP hike is a welcome step and will boost the farmers’ income but will remain limited to a small per centage of households. Of the total crop, only 25 per cent of paddy is procured under MSP, the rest are left to market forces. This will raise the aspiration levels of the farmers and may prove counter-productive for the government. Only 7 per cent to 10 per cent of the farmers get benefitted by MSP and rest of them run from pillar to post to dispose of their produce. So MSP is not an answer to India’s Agriculture crisis, he added.

Let’s take a look at the preparation of the Government. The targets for the Kharif procurement would be taken up in a meeting lined up for July 31, informed the sources in food ministry. The procurement of wheat also jumped the target this year- against the target of 33 million tonne, 35 million tonne was procured.

There is an urgent need to augment the storage capacity with the procurement agencies lest the precious grain is piled up in an unscientific manner to serve the rodents. The Food Corporation of India has 70 million tonne storage capacity but there remains a space crunch during the harvesting season. The Shanta Kumar Committee gave its recommendations for restructuring of Food Corporation of India in 2015 to plug the leakages in storage and bring more farmers to the ambit of procurement. Nothing concrete has come out. There was a proposal of developing small silo hubs in villages on PPP model so that farmers need not transport the produce to distant markets but the files are biting the dust. Government agencies find it difficult to organise land for such causes.

The trade experts are sanguine over the MSP hike but at the same time apprehensive over the benefit to farmers. Dilip Bhai Patel, President of All Gujarat Cotton Ginners Association told that increase in farmers’ income is beneficial for the entire economy but the intermediaries in the commodity market are a threat to the producers. The transportation of crop from the farm gate to market yard makes farmers dependent on intermediaries who skew the terms-of-trade for their own benefit.

Vijay Tayal, the General Secretary of All India Rice Millers Association finds the MSP hike as a politically motivated decision. “Farmers need long-term solutions to make farming a profitable venture, ” he added.

The visit of Prime Minister Narendra Modi to Malout in Punjab on July 11, in a thanksgiving rally jointly organised by the ally Shiromani Alaki Dal and BJP (Punjab), uncovers the intentions of the Government behind MSP hike. Far from farmers’ welfare, it’s a pure political decision eyeing the electoral gains.

letters@tehelka.com

MOST POPULAR

HOT NEWS