Page 12 - Tehelka Issue 8&9
P. 12

Railways                                                                                                                                                                                                      kashmir





         A                            Railways’ finance                              Railways Finance Corporation        is Centre relaxing                                the centre’s new Kashmir in-  country and the separatists
                  scrutiny of
                                                                                                                                                                           terlocutor Dineshwar Sharma  have a right to carry out their
                  the report on
                                                                                     (IRFC). The debt burden of In-
                                         in diRe stRaits!
                                                                                                                                                                           has indicated such a change.
                                                                                                                                                                                                    activities democratically,”
                                                                                     dian Railways will ultimately
                  financial status of
                                                                                                                         its iron-fist
                                                                                                                                                                                                    said Ashok Kaul, the BJP’s J&K
                                                                                                                                                                             “There are more decisions
                  Indian Railways
                                                                                     be borne by the next genera-
                  presented with
                                                                                                                                                                                                    ratists will have to carry out
                                                                                       Railways internal revenues
         the General Budget 2018-19 in                                               tions of people.                                                                      in offing,” Dineshwar Sharma   spokesperson. “But the sepa-
                                                                                                                                                                           has told the media. “You will
         the Parliament paints dismal   Massive investments needed to maintain balance   in 2018-19 are estimated at     poliCy on Kashmir?                                see a change, a big change.”  their activities peacefully. This
         picture of its financial health   between commercial status and social responsibil-  2.01 lakh crore, a seven per                                                   However, New Delhi has   has been conveyed to them.”
         indicating that the railways   ity of the Indian Railways, writes M.Y.Siddiqui  cent higher than the revised                                                      so far stayed short of offering   But such a shift when the
         have to remain financially                                                  estimates for 2017-18, which        So far, the NDA government has practiced          talks to the Hurriyat. Even   NDA government is entering
         viable on borrowed money                                                    comes from freight, passen-         hard-nosed policy towards the state that has only   Sharma has left it to the wis-  in its last year in the power
         from market and other                                                       gers and sundry earnings.                                                             dom of the separatist leaders   means too little, too late –
         sources. As a result of merger                                              Revenue from freight and            made things difficult in the Valley, writes Riyaz Wani  “to take a call” on engaging   albeit forced possibly by the
         of Railways budget with the                                                 passenger traffic is estimated                                                        New Delhi. This has meant   realisation that its hard-nosed
         General Budget since 2017-18,                                               at  2 lakh crore. However,              s centre changing tack   ment has so far practised an   that the centre expects the   policy so far has only made
         Railways escaped dedicated                                                  over past few years, internal           on Kashmir? It looks   iron-fisted policy towards the   initiative for the dialogue to   things further difficult in the
         media focus and for that                                                    revenue from freight and pas-           like it is, but not quite.   state. Soon after he was sworn  be taken by the Hurriyat itself,  state. In recent past, there has
         matter public scrutiny of its                                               senger services is falling short        On March 30, in an   in 2014, Prime Minister Nar-  chances of which are remote.   been mounting opinion in the
         overall functioning alto-                                                   of the targets.                    I unusual decision, the   endra Modi embarked upon a  As a result, there is little hope   state that the centre should
         gether, the casualty being the                                                Added to the above,               state government decided   no-compromise hardline ap-  of an engagement between   relax its tough policy towards
         impugned report on its finan-                                               expenditure on salaries and         to let the top separatist trio   proach to control the ongoing  the two in the near future.  the state.
         cial status from public notice.                                             pension is increasing operat-       — Syed Ali Geelani, Mirwaiz   runaway upsurge in Kashmir.  But, this hardly detracts   “Such an approach ensures
         That is how Indian Railways                                                 ing expenditure for 2018-19,        Umer Farooq and Yasin Malik   But four years on, there   from the significance of giving  that the turmoil in Kashmir
         have lost its sheen in public                                               estimated at  1.88 lakh crore,      – carry out their political   is little that has changed in   Hurriyat leaders some space   will linger on,” stated a recent
         glare. It comes on the fore in                                              up 4 per cent from 2017-18.         activities but with a rider: they  Kashmir. Militancy, which   to ply their politics. More so,   editorial of a local English
         public domain only when ac-                                                   About 66 per cent of this         should not create a law and   was sought to be curbed,   when even the BJP has batted   daily. “One would expect
         cidents take place with heavy                                               goes to salary and pension,         order problem nor make anti- has grown from strength to   for such a space terming the   the central government to
         casualties.                                                                 which has been increasing           national speeches.       strength, despite an increas-  government decisions to   understand the gravity of the
           Indicator of financial   budget) of Railways being   • Debt trap Total debt of Railways   gradually, with a jump of 15   A day later they were even   ing number of the killings of   free separatists as part of the   situation and take incremen-
         health of Indian Railways is   financed from borrowings.   may cross  600,000 crore  per cent in the last two years   allowed to attend and address  the militants.   Confidence Building Measure  tal steps to address the larger
         its Operating Ratio, which is   With declining revenue from                 on account of implemen-             the March 30 congregations.   So, has the centre finally   (CBM).          political issue that is primarily
         on the higher side currently.   generation of freight, passen-              tation of the Seventh Pay           But a few days later, the state   woken up to the deteriorat-  “India is a democratic   responsible for the turmoil in
         Operating Ratio is the ratio of   ger and sundry earnings, capi- ings followed by 37 per cent   Commission Report. Pension   government again placed   ing situation in the state and      the state.”
         working expenditure, arising   tal outlay is financed through   budgetary support and only   bill is also to rise as about 40   them under house arrest   started trying some outreach,      But, the fact that the time
         from day to day operations, to  budgetary support from the   8 per cent from railways own   per cent of staff are above 50   when twenty people died in   beginning with the top   • Laws flaws Separatists have   for such a policy shift may
         revenue earned from traffic.   Central Government (General  earnings (internal resources).   years in 2016-17.   three encounters in South   separatist leadership? It does   advised not create a law and    have already run out is also
         A higher Operating Ration   Exchequer) and market bor-  Capital expenditure (develop-  In short, capital expendi-  Kashmir — thirteen of them   appear so. And, no less than   order problem in Kashmir  not lost on the Kashmir
         indicates a poorer ability of   rowings. Since 2017-18, when   ment budget of Railways) is   ture of Indian Railways is   militants, four civil-                                                observers.
         Railways to generate surplus   Railway Budget merged with   increasingly being financed   increasingly being financed   ians and three security                                                   “This apparent policy
         that can be used for capital   the General Budget, Railways   through borrowings, from 8   through borrowings from 8   personnel.                                                               shift makes little sense
         investments in moderniza-  have been exempted from   percent of total development   per cent in 2010-11 to 55 per-  The government                                                              now. There is little time
         tion, laying lines and deploy-  paying annual dividend to   budget in 2010-11 to 55 per   cent in 2018-19, a sorry state of   decision to cut sepa-                                             left for the new policy
         ing more coaches. Operating   the General Exchequer on the  cent in 2018-19. Economists   railways financial viability. It   ratists some slack still                                           to make an impact,”
         Ratio for 2018-19 is projected   accumulated capital at charge  view it as a sure road to debt   calls for massive investments   stands. They could still                                       says the analyst and
         at 92.8 per cent from revised   from budgetary support.  trap for Indian Railways rais-  by the Union Government to   be allowed to hold their                                                  commentator Gowher
         estimates of 2017-18 which   In 2018-19, gross budgetary  ing its financial difficulties.  maintain balance between   activities as long as the                                                 Geelani. “But if the
         was over 96 per cent. During   support from the Central Gov-  Total debt of Indian Rail-  commercial status and   government doesn’t                                                            centre is sincere and
         the past few years, Operating   ernment (General Exchequer)  ways stood at over  450,000   social responsibility of Indian   apprehend a law and                                                serious about a political
         Ratio has been around 94 per   is at  55,088 crore, while bor-  crore in 2014-15. Taking in   Railways as the one and only   order issue. And, therein                                          outreach and willing to
         cent on average, which means  rowings are estimated at    accounts the ever increasing   modes of mass transporta-  lies the potential shift                                                    resolve issues, there is
         Railways are spending 94   81,940 crore. Out of  148,000  annual borrowings in 2015-16,  tion of bulk of our people who   in the stance towards                                                 no reason it shouldn’t
         paise out of every rupee that   crore capital expenditure (an-  2016-17 and 2018-19, it is    cannot afford other modes of   Kashmir. And if this is so,                                        make a redeeming
         it earns.                nual plan outlay) for the fiscal   likely to go up by more than    transportation!     it is happening for the                                                         difference.”
           Net result has been capital   year 2018-19,  55 percent will   600,000 crore. The borrow-                     first time in the last four
         expenditure (development   be financed through borrow-  ing arms of Railways is Indian   letters@tehelka.com    years. The NDA govern-                                                               letters@tehelka.com



                                          Tehelka / 15 may 2018  12  www.Tehelka.com                                                                      Tehelka / 15 may 2018  13  www.Tehelka.com



   12 Ralways.indd   3                                                                                02/05/18   5:25 PM  13 Riyaz.indd   3                                                                          02/05/18   5:26 PM
   7   8   9   10   11   12   13   14   15   16   17