Page 58 - English Tehelka Issue 1&2
P. 58

column





                                       Patriotism? Let cinema


                                       hall owners decide




                                       The much-talked about issue of the national anthem playing in
         Being You                     cinema halls is once again on the forefront as our patriotism now
                                       lies in the hands of cinema owners
         Yashica
         Jalhotra

                                               he national anthem has been   people including elderly and kids when
         The writer, currently                 the talk of the town for quite   my phone rang displaying the name of
         Editor (Digital Media),               sometime. On November     the caller saved in my phone as “don’t
         is noted for giving witty             30, 2016, the Supreme Court   pick”.
         tips on current issues,       T made it mandatory to play         Ankit was calling as he had gone
         lifestyle, health, love,      the anthem in cinema halls before the   through SC’s national anthem ruling
         parenting, behaviour,         screening of films, saying that those   and wanted me to listen to arguments
         inner-self, spirituality,     present must “stand up in respect”    that he wanted me to publish. But as my
         beliefs,relationships         till the anthem ended. The reason   mobile suggested “don’t pick”, I didn’t
         and everything else           behind this order as given by the apex   take the call until my colleague was
         under the sun.                court was to “instil within one a sense    obviously irritated with my continuous
                                       of committed patriotism and
                                       nationalism.”                        Some cinema
                                         The bench of Justices Dipak Misra
                                       and Amitava Roy said it was time     owners said they
                                       people expressed their “love for the   were in a tight
                                       motherland.”
                                         “People must feel this is my country.   spot many times
                                       This is my motherland. Who are you?
                                       You are an Indian first. In other coun-  when some people                                 • matter of choice  So, now cinema owners have the authority to decide when to instil love for the nation in people?
                                       tries, you respect their restrictions.    got agitated
                                       In India, you do not want any restric-
                                       tions?” Justice Misra had remarked.    seeing someone                                     route of pirated CDs.        that should a cinema hall choose to   theatre owners said they would like
                                       “...people should feel that they live in    not standing                                    For me, the judgment was a   play the national anthem, it shall be  to continue playing the national
                                       a nation and show respect to the                                                          boon. Thanks to the judges, in   compulsory for every person in the   anthem.
                                       national anthem and the national flag,”   during the anthem                               order to “stand up in respect” for   audience to stand in respect unless   So now cinema owners have the
                                       he said.                                                                                  the nation, I became attentive, in   they are entitled to exemption on   authority to decide when to instil
                                         ‘Oh C’mon! Do we really need forced                                                     cinemas at least. The decision gave   account of disability.  love for the nation in people?
                                       patriotism?’ was my first thought after   ringtone of “saare jahan se achha…hindu-        me a reason to stand before I go on   So, does that mean that now   Here goes my reverie of stand-
                                       the decision came. We in the twenty-  stan hamara”.                                       my munching spree for the next   cinema owners will decide when I   ing in a queue to buy a ticket for the
                                       first century cant be forced to listen to   We Indians have a very strange habit          three hours.                 need to bring my attentiveness back  latest blockbuster and get to know
                                       our national anthem to feel deep love,   of doing what we are told not to do.               I was overwhelmed by love for   in theatres? The current order is   that patriotism is free with every
                                       respect and responsibility towards the   The apex court wanted to instil patriot-         my motherland until the judges   perplexing for me.        ticket.
                                       nation.                           ism in us but going by habit, many of                   decided to give a revised judg-  The decision has again got a
                                         Going through this unique news   my friends exchanged a lot of ideas                    ment on January 9 this year. While   mixed response from theatre own-  Yashica Jalhotra is very happy
                                       2016, I had perfect fodder ready for my   on how to go against the decision. So           modifying its earlier order, the   ers. Some of them welcomed the   after the apex court’s decision as
                                       daydreaming routine in office. After all,   the result was that I was the only one        SC made playing of the national   judgment saying that many times   she can now choose the theatre
                                       who wanted to work if there was such   from my group going to the movies                  anthem in cinema halls optional.   they faced uncomfortable situa-  according to her patriotic mood of
                                       big news out there to gossip about. So,   throughout last year. To not indulge            However, the twist came when the   tions when some people would get   the day.
                                       here I was in my reverie, sitting in the   in forced patriotism, my friends boy-          court gave control in the hands of   agitated seeing someone not stand-
                                       middle row of a cinema hall filled with   cotted cinemas altogether and took the          cinema owners. The bench clarified  ing during the anthem. Some other    letters@tehelka.com



                                       Tehelka / 31 january 2018  58  www.Tehelka.com                                                                  Tehelka / 31 january 2018  59  www.Tehelka.com



   58-59 Being-u-Column.indd   2-3                                                                                                                                                                                   12/01/18   4:15 PM
   53   54   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63