Page 50 - English Tehelka Issue 12 - June 30, 2018
P. 50

health




         Need to pay attention to                                                                                        remained the same. Stakeholders have   India. Women with unwanted preg-  partners. Women are discouraged from


                                                                                                                                                         nancies, in rural and semi-urban ar-
                                                                                                                         struggled to take the common man in
                                                                                                                                                                                          using temporary contraception by their
         India’s illegal abortions                                                                                       to the fold and operationalise the act in  eas, are often hesitant to go to doctors   own peers. Male contraception is rarely
                                                                                                                                                         due to family pressure and privacy is-
                                                                                                                                                                                          used and even more inconsistent in
                                                                                                                         a way that provides women to control
                                                                                                                         over their own reproductive choices
                                                                                                                                                         sues. Midwives, quacks and unqualified  steady relationships. The condom usage
                                                                                                                                                                                          in India is a dismal 5 per cent. As Nina
                                                                                                                         and rights. Religious, social and cultural  RMPs use unsafe methods to induce
                                                                                                                         issues, in addition to rampant miscon-  abortions such as insertion of sticks and  puts it, “ Men only use condoms when
                                                                                                                         ceptions, restrict the use of contracep-  roots, ingestion of herbal medicines,   they have a fear of getting a disease like
         Over 75 per cent abortions estimated to occur in India annually are done bereft of health facilities            tion. Out of an annual estimate of 48.1   abortifacient drugs, abdominal mas-  AIDS. Why would they use it with their
         and around 5-7 per cent abortions that are done outside licensed facilities use other methods that are          million pregnancies, half are unintend-  sage and incomplete D&Cs in unhy-  wives or girlfriends?”
                                                                                                                                                                                            Over the last decade, Indian courts
         possibly dangerous. The figure may be higher as non-institutionalised abortions cannot be recorded.             ed and a third of them result in abor-  gienic conditions. It can lead to sepsis/  have issued several notable judgements
                                                                                                                         tions. Only obstetricians and gynaecol-
                                                                                                                                                         infection, which if left untreated may
         The situation is even worse for single and divorced women and those living in rural regions,                    ogists, just over 34,000 nationally, can   even cause death. Other side effects are  recognising  women’s  reproductive
                                                                                                                         provide abortions. Thus the number of   internal haemorrhage, injuries to vital   rights as a part of the ‘inalienable sur-
         reports subhangi singh                                                                                          approved abortion providers in India   organs and future infertility. We often   vival rights’, implicitly protected under
         A                                counter medical abortion (MA) pills                                                                            due to abortions                 these landmark judgements recognise
                                                                                                                                                         get critical cases with ruptured uteri
                                                                                                                                                                                          the fundamental right to life. Some of
                  dozen  women  are  sit -
                                                                                                                                                            gone bad but some of these unmar-
                                                                                                                                                                                          these rights as essential for equality of
                                          without prescription, they are easily
                  ting around a lavish living
                  room in Chandigarh, full
                                          available due to lack of proper verifica-
                                                                                                                                                         ried young girls still refuse to admit that  women and urged them to have great-
                                                                                                                                                                                          er autonomy and powers of decision-
                  of bubbling chatter and
                                          tion by small chemist shops and ease
                  cocktail flutes. A gripping
                                          of distribution from unlicensed sourc-
         game called ‘Never Have I Ever’ is in full  es. According to a study published in                                                                                                making concerning their pregnancies.
                                                                                                                                                                                          In 2014, some much-needed amend-
         swing. Nina (name changed) raises her   the Lancet, MA pills accounted for over                                                                   India was one of the           ments were proposed for the MTP Act.
         glass and declares, “Never have I ever   80 per cent of all abortions in 2015.                                                                                                   Alas! they were sent back for revision
         had an abortion!” The room suddenly   These pills, though safe for terminat-                                                                      earliest countries             and are still stuck under the prover-
         falls silent and everybody, except Nina,   ing early pregnancies under proper                                                                     that legalised                 bial red tape. Laws to prevent pre-natal
         takes a sip from their respective glasses.  medical guidance, can be considered                                                                                                  sex selection (PCPNDT Act) and sexual
         It is a kitty party. Most of the women are  illegal  and  unsafe.  Impetuous  and                                                                 abortions. In                  offences against minors (POSCO Act)
         married. The conversation invariably   recurrent usage of MA pills can lead                                                                       fact, the Medical              have outdated clauses that often lead
         veers towards recurrent abortions in   to incomplete abortions, infections                                                                                                       to confusion, interference and harass-
         married and divorced women. Nina   as well as future infertility. More than                                                                       Termination of                 ment of genuine medical and pharma-
         whispers that Shehnaz (name changed)  75 per cent of the 15.6 million abortions                                                                   Pregnancy Act, 1971,           ceutical practitioners, who are becom-
         tops the list as “she keeps having these   estimated to occur in India annually                                                                                                  ing increasingly reluctant to provide
         abortions now and then.”         are done outside of health facilities and                                                                        legalised abortion             abortion services.
           Shehnaz is a 36-year-old married   half of them are unsafe. Around 5-7 per                                                                                                       The lack of awareness and sensitisa-
         woman with two young kids. She sighs,  cent abortions done outside licensed                                                                       up to 20 weeks                 tion amongst Indian women regard-
         “I had both my kids within the first   facilities use other methods that are                                                                                                     ing their reproductive rights, social
         three years of my marriage. We did not  possibly dangerous. They result in 9                                                                                                     stigma,  complicated  and  outdated
         want any more kids but my husband   per cent of all maternal deaths in India.                                                                   they have been sexually active.”  laws, governmental ignorance and
         does not like condoms. The third time   The actual figure may be higher as non-                                                                    The patriarchal mindset results in   shortage of licensed abortion provid-
         I got pregnant, I visited a local gynae-  institutionalised abortions cannot be                                                                 preference of the male child. Despite   ers have led to illegal and unsafe abor-
         cologist who prescribed me an abortion  recorded. The situation is even worse                                                                   crackdowns on potential offenders,   tion methods threatening to become a
         kit called Unwanted. After that, when-  for single/divorced women and those                                                                     quacks and midwives often use unre-  pandemic that can easily be prevented.
         ever I get pregnant, I just go to a chemist  in rural regions.   stantial risk’, etc. In India, where female    is too low compared to the number of   liable methods to predict the sex of an   As we join hands with the world to de-
         and buy the same kit, using the old pre-  India was one of earliest countries   sexuality is controlled, stigmatised and   women in need. Moreover, these prac-  unborn child, thus leading to unsafe   mand amendments in Irish abortion
         scription. It’s easier and no-one gets to   to legalise abortion. The Medical Termi-  exists supplementary to male sexuality,   titioners are mostly concentrated in   abortions in case of unfavourable news.  laws after the tragic death of Dr Savita
         know. I don’t want to create discord in   nation of Pregnancy Act, 1971, legalised   a woman bears the burden of explain-  urban areas. So women are compelled   Indian women, who often lack financial  Halappanavar, maybe it is time to look
         the house by haggling over such trivial    abortions up to 20 weeks but the law   ing how carrying a pregnancy to term   to approach illegal, unqualified provid-  freedom and/or authority in a house-  inwards at our own abortion laws. We
         issues.” Shehnaz has not kept count of   left the onus on the opinion of licensed  may harm her physical/mental health.   ers, thereby endangering their lives and  hold, rarely have the right to choose   need to introspect as a society whether
         the number of abortions she has had.   medical practitioners. Sadly, they can   So a woman cannot simply demand an   health.                    their own reproductive future. In a so-  we are ready to give our women true
         This is a sad reality in India, where   be judgmental as a part of a skewed    abortion. Such a law does not affirm a   According to Dr Shefali Wadhwani   ciety where talking about sex is a big   equality by recognising their absolute
         abortion is used as the go-to method to  society. Moreover, the MTP Act fails to   woman’s reproductive rights.  Sharma, a gynaecologist at GMCH,   taboo and child-bearing is considered   right to reproductive choice and hence
         space out children or even as a casual   define terms like ‘abortion’, ‘miscar-  During the last four decades, despite   Chandigarh, ”Low acceptability of ex-  a woman’s responsibility, most men are  their own bodies.
         alternative to generic contraception.  riage’, ‘termination of pregnancy’, ‘med-  technological advancements and ease   plicit contraception means that illegal   reluctant to get involved in maternal
           Despite a ban on the sale of over the  ical & surgical abortion’, ‘health’, ‘sub-  of abortion procedures, the law has   abortions are still rampant in rural   health and reproductive issues of their   letters@tehelka.com
                                          tehelka / 30 june 2018  50  www.tehelka.com                                                                    tehelka / 30 june 2018  51  www.tehelka.com



   50-51 Subhangi Singh.indd   2                                                                     16/06/18   12:26 PM  50-51 Subhangi Singh.indd   3                                                              16/06/18   12:27 PM
   45   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   54   55